Comparing incandescent and LED

LEDing the Way – Lumens and Efficiency

Like these posts on LED lighting?
Click here to see them all.

We’re all familiar with incandescent lights. They’re a very, very mature technology: highly standardized sizes, with known expectations for light output of different wattage bulbs. We all have an intuitive idea of how much light a 60W bulb puts out, right? But if we’re buying LED bulbs, we need to become acquainted with the light output measurement that lighting designers and engineers use to compare lights. Light intensity is measured in lumens (lm). Here are some useful figures for good ole incandescent bulbs:

WattsBulb TypeLumens
60WA19/E26/E12800 lm
100WA19/E261600 lm
65WBR30620 lm
75WPAR301100 lm
10Whalogen80 – 150 lm
20Whalogen170 – 250 lm
50Whalogen400 – 550 lm

Brightness of Common Incandescent Bulbs

You’ll find the lumen rating on the packaging of most bulbs and included in product descriptions on websites. If they don’t tell you how many lumens and just say something like “75W equivalent”, beware! A lot of product descriptions on sites like Amazon or Home Depot are tweaked to make LED bulbs seem brighter than they actually are, by equating them to wattage equivalents for incandescent bulbs. But lumens don’t lie – a 400 lm MR16 halogen bulb at 50W is just about the same brightness as a 435 lm LED MR16 replacement bulb at 7.5W, but the LED is 6.6x as efficient.

Comparing incandescent and LED
60 W, 780 lm incandescent on left, 9.5 W, 800 lm LED on right, 6.3 times as efficient

A common way to express efficiency is in lumens/watt. California, defying the Trump Administration’s DOE who are eager to gut efficiency mandates from earlier administrations including G.W. Bush and Obama, requires most bulbs sold in California to deliver at least 45 lm / watt efficiency. Nearly everything you’ll find in standard bulb replacements meets this requirement. That LED bulb example above is 58 lm / watt. The halogen is just 8 lm / watt.

While efficiency is important, if you sacrifice other characteristics you want for maximum efficiency, you’ll be saving the planet a tiny bit better, but you’ll hate your lights. All LEDs are efficient, so don’t stress too much about it. Stress a lot more about the other stuff I will tell you about in later posts!

One thought on “LEDing the Way – Lumens and Efficiency

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Google photo

You are commenting using your Google account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s